Pomodoro's Italian Eatery

Note: The owner or a representative of this business has not yet completed the verification process

See more Terms of Service

4.3

( 8 reviews )

Food Delivery Services, Burgers $$

Open 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM See Hours

90 Catskill Cmns, Catskill, NY 12414, United States

+1 5189-434-446

Introducing Pomodoro's Italian Eatery, a rustic restaurant located in Catskill, NY. Known for its typical Italian entrees and sandwiches, as well as delicious pizzas offered whole or by the slice, Pomodoro's is a go-to spot for authentic Italian cuisine. With options for dine-in, kerbside pickup, and no-contact delivery, the restaurant aims to cater to its customers' preferences. The cozy ambiance and friendly staff make Pomodoro's a perfect choice for a casual meal or a special night out. The menu boasts a variety of options, including mouthwatering pizzas, calzones, sandwiches, main dishes, and wraps. Offering good food, great service, and fair prices, Pomodoro's Italian Eatery is sure to satisfy any craving for Italian cuisine.

Reviews

4.3/5

8 reviews

5 stars

4 stars

3 stars

2 stars

1 stars

Brandy m

March 22, 2024

As a Jersey girl, it’s hard for me to fall in love with an Italian eatery, especially the pizza. Wonderful atmosphere! The pizza was fabulous, they used real minced garlic on it and it was to die for! It was baked perfectly, the pictures really don’t do it justice. The staff was amazing and even treated me to a cannoli for my 20th birthday!

Sanel aganovic

March 22, 2024

We've always had a fine experience at Pomodoro's - they serve good comfort food in a casual atmosphere, and it's been a great place to visit in-between errands when we're in the area. Recently my son left something at the restaurant and they went above and beyond to return it to him, we were so touched by their kindness. It was great for my son to experience customer service like this as a young adult, and as a parent, I appreciated it so much. We always liked Pomodoro's before, but now as a result of this experience, we're loyal customers! Oh and also? My son says the calamari is 'top notch' and we both love the cheesy garlic bread!

Daryl miller

March 22, 2024

Friendly and inviting staff with pretty good Italian (pizzeria) food. Prices are fair. Portions are fair if you stop by. Don't think you'll be disappointed. Give it a try!

Judi redmond

March 22, 2024

The food here at times can be a hit or a miss. Today was a miss for me. I ordered a simple meal, fried calamari, 2 cream of broccoli soups and mozzarella sticks with raspberry sauce with extra raspberry sauce ($.75 cent). The soup was chunky, not creamy. I didn't receive any raspberry sauce. I had to use marinara sauce instead. I honestly don't ever leave a tip, but today I did and it was a miss. The fried calamari was ok.

Ali elghoul

March 22, 2024

I have eaten at Pomodoros many many times through the years but always with varying degrees of satisfaction. There are months on end when food is reliable and service is great, then there are times when the pizzas are two inches smaller in diameter and the food is subpar. Got a burger for takeout today, asked for medium, not rare and not medium rare...I got a burger that I would describe as "flame kissed." If it were rare that would be one thing, but this was literally raw burger. I had to put it in the microwave when I got home just to be able to stomach it. Between that, their mild wings being insanely flaming hot, and the 'fresh from the box' Mac and cheese bites my son got, I won't be going back for awhile. I would recommend scrapping the frozen appetizers and coming up with something else.

Kagebeauty

March 22, 2024

Whenever I'm in the area of Catskill we always pay a visit for a quick slice. Pizza is ok, but definitely not what you'd find in NYC. Visiting Garfield on top of the beverage machine is always a must do to start our trip. He even has a new little friend next to him.

Sherrie davidson

March 22, 2024

My wife and I have been coming here for 6 years since we moved to the area. After reading many bad reviews today im actually shocked. The Food is always great I usually get salad with house dressing and chicken parm dinner. Or Buffalo chicken wrap with fries. Like I said Food has always been great. We have been getting takeout over the last 3 years due to having many kids we don't want to drag them in there and disrupt anyone. They can get a little wild at points. They were always busy when we went on Friday nights or Saturday. You Gotta get there early or later.

Dusty maat

March 22, 2024

I can't speak on service or atmosphere bc I ordered delivery with my fellow coworkers. On that note. They warned me... They ONLY ever order chicken wings from this establishment bc the wings are always good. I foolishly ordered a Ceasar salad...it was literally the worst Ceasar salad I've ever eaten. Romaine soggy, croutons subpar and whatever you thought was Ceasars dressing is DEFINITELY not Ceasars dressing.based off this botched salad, I won't order from you ever again..although my coworkers were happy with your wings, I STILL won't order from you ever again. Whoever made this salad needs to be retrained. A foodie should never fall any food the worst they've ever had. DO BETTER, ur always packed when I drive by, so your food quality should reflect that.